top of page

Forum Comments

The Round Table of Camelyn
In ASK US ANYTHING
Greg
Jan 04, 2024
Thank you for the Rulebook Paul. I've already started modifying the new content in the French version while translating to Spanish. As for the comics, I should have been more specific but I was short of time: I was giving you two examples of what in my opinion are absolute works of art made without modern technologies. My point is more, for comic, that using a computer, you still need to know drawing techniques. On the contrary, using more than 50% AI is something different, that I wouldn't appreciate personnaly as art. As for your argument about the author feeling free to develop the story because they would not need to draw the same background again and again, well, I suppose that is why most authors work in pairs: it is a synergy between a scenarist and a graphics artist. Few do both, but anyway in my opinion it is their job and what they love, no matter the time it takes. I will not enter in the commercial debate since I do not have enough knowledge about that, and it is not something new, just reinforced by AI I think. As any new technology, the issue is how you use it, not the tech itself. What bothers me most, in the case of ChatGPT, is thinking about WHO created it, with all the cultural and economical bias it implies. And ot still does a lot of basic mistakes: you certainly have noticed that a few weeks ago Gamefound started offering other languages than English in their platform. I already have detected several big "horrors" in French and Spanish, and I told them. They said "thank you, we use an AI and the help of native backers". Well, no comment... So I can guarantee you my translations are 100% "nuts free". Anyway, it is a great debate (in the end we are in and it is my fault!) and a very necessary one, because it is the first time a tool is ment to be a substitute not for our workforce (machines), nor our memory (internet, and that is proving to be a big issue in my job), but our very imagination and creativity. Yes, I say "replacing", because Homo Sapiens is lazy, and he always goes the esiaest way. My biggest fear is that AI will create a big "chasm" between the few that will still know how to do things, and a mass of people hipnotized by screens and virtual friends. Yes, I know, to much Orwell, to much Black mirror, but sometimes I am glad I do not have any children! Going back to work, have a great day!
3
1
The Round Table of Camelyn
In ASK US ANYTHING
Greg
Jan 03, 2024
I have to say I really admire you trying and discover how AI works in your "sector", especially considering we are the same age (Too old to Rock'n'Roll, too young to die, as Ian Anderson said long time ago!). As a teacher, this year has been particularly interesting, confusing, puzzling and self-questioning: I have discovered I could ask ChatGPT to prepare my classes, structure the exams and correct them, translate any proof so I can "steal" activities from my English, German, Italian and Spanish (as a foreign language) colleagues... Anything! For short, I could be payed to do almost nothing. Is this how I see my job? Definitely not. Am I in any way saying you or John Howe (I don't know about Alan Lee) are wrong? Not at all. As anybody, I'm trying to adapt to a world going faster and faster. But still, for comics, I stick to my opinion, because of this https://www.bedetheque.com/serie-4-BD-Peter-Pan-Loisel.html or that https://www.bedetheque.com/serie-42820-BD-Wika.html (or Miyazaki, as you wrote about Disney). No AI, not even computer, no way! Artists don't need to rush. As for TTRPG, well, a friend of mine started to use ChatGPT to prepare his adventures. Result? Boring and unpersonal, and he is on of the best Game Masters I've ever known. No more philosophy for today, let's just say that Humanity is facing one of its biggest challenge ever and I'm not sure what's going to happen in the next years. The choice is ours. And yes, yes, "marsterrrrr" (whipping noises), I go back to my translations!
3
1
The Round Table of Camelyn
In ASK US ANYTHING
Greg
Dec 20, 2023
🤤
1
0
The Round Table of Camelyn
In ASK US ANYTHING
Greg
Nov 24, 2023
Great thing indeed!
The Round Table of Camelyn
In ASK US ANYTHING
The Round Table of Camelyn
In ASK US ANYTHING
Greg
Nov 20, 2023
Spring is great too!

Greg

More actions
bottom of page